Go to Home Page

Click Here to Go to Index for All Media Server Reviews

 

Product Review
 

Kaleidescape Media Server

Part I

December, 2004

John E. Johnson, Jr.

 

Specifications:

Reader:
 

● DVD Transport
● Connection: 100Base-TX Ethernet

● Dimensions: 1.7" H x 17.2" W x 14" D

● Rack Mount

● Weight: 10 Pounds
   


Player:


● Video Formats: NTSC 480i/480p, PAL
    576i/576p, 720p, 1080i

● Audio Formats: Dolby Digital, DTS, MPEG, PCM

● Video Outputs: HDMI, Component YPbPr, S-
    Video, Composite

● Faroudja DCDi

● Audio Outputs: HDMI, Digital Coaxial, Digital
    Toslink, Analog Stereo

● Other Connections: 100Base-TX Ethernet,
    RS232, TCP/IP, IR

● Dimensions: 1.7" H x 17.2" W x 14.5" D

● Rack Mount

● Weight: 11 Pounds

Server:


● Accommodates 12 300 GB Cartridges

● Additional Servers Can Be Added

● Connections: 100Base-TX Ethernet

● Dimensions: 8.7" H x 17.2" W x 18" D

● Weight: 78 Pounds
 

System Price (with hard drive space for 180 movies): $27,000 USA

 

Kaleidescape

www.kaleidescape.com 

 Introduction

My first computer was a Radio Shack, way back in the early 1980's. It had 64 kB of RAM - bragging about it with a label on the computer front - and the operating system, along with the word processor, were all contained on one floppy disk that had to be inserted each time I turned the computer on in the morning.

About a year or so after I bought the computer, Radio Shack announced a hard drive as an accessory. It had 5 MB of disc space and cost $5,000. I am sure they sold a bunch of them, but I could not afford one.

Now, hard drives with hundreds of GB space can be had for $400 each.

This is important to home theater enthusiasts, because movies can be stored on hard drives, but they take up a lot of space. A typical 2 hour movie is around 7 GB, stored on a dual-layer DVD. That original Radio Shack hard drive would have stored only 4 seconds of a DVD movie!

But a hard drive with 300 GB of space . . . ah, now we have some room. Room in fact for more than 40 movies.

So, with the advent of such large hard drives, it was a given that companies would start to offer "Media Servers" that could deliver movies to TV displays around our homes. Since these movie servers are basically computers, we could, of course, build them ourselves and save a few bucks. However, movie servers require several hard drives, dedicate software to run them, and, if we want to take advantage of high definition TV, the ability to output 720p and 1080i through HDCP-enabled outputs. This gets to be rather complicated, especially if you want some nice customized user interfaces that let you point and select movies. So . . . enter commercial media servers.

The Kaleidescape System

Kaleidescape, founded in 2001 and located in Northern California (Mountain View), does just one thing. They build media servers. Most of us probably have not heard of Kaleidescape before. The product is very specialized, and has gone into home theaters of such luminaries as George Lucas.

It is a very expensive product, but building one yourself would be expensive too, not to mention the hassle of making it work properly. However, it is the user interface that makes the Kaleidescape system a dream to work with, and their interface has won industrial awards http://www.kaleidescape.com/files/pressreleases/Kaleidescape-IDEA-2004.pdf.

The Kaleidescape has everything one needs: a Reader (DVD transport), a Player (hardware decoders and outputs), and a Server (hard drives and associated circuitry). Currently, the Kaleidescape is only for movies, but in the future, you will be able to store and serve music (CDs) as well.

The system weighs about 100 pounds and is designed for rack mounting, at about 15" high for all three components sitting one on top of the other. Some consumers will probably want to have the transport and player nearby, while the server can sit in another room. (All three components are connected together with Ethernet Cat-5 cables/100Base-TX.) However, the transport is not for playing DVDs through your display. It is a "Reader" that is only used to load your DVDs onto the server's hard drives. So, actually the entire system can sit away from your main component rack, which is what I did for the review. If it is not within eyesight, you would need an RF remote control, and the system has in input for remote control triggers on the back.

The Reader only has one purpose (to load DVDs into the server), and it has one button on the front, to open and close the tray. The Player is a closed box and does its thing internally. However, the server is much more interesting to look at.

Pulling the server door open reveals twelve slots for hard drives. To remove and replace drives, or to add more drives, a tab on the front of the drive is opened, and the drive removed. The review unit had five 300 GB drives, and the remaining seven slots had empty drive boxes inserted to maintain proper air flow. In the photo below, you can see blue LEDs on the front of five drive bays, indicating that these are active slots. The other seven have white dots, but no LEDs, indicating empty slots. Blue lights at the bottom indicate that the system is operating properly.

The hard drives are “hot-pluggable” which means that you can, while the system is powered on, add hard drives or remove and replace a failed drive (a failed drive is indicated by an amber light). To remove a failed drive, you fold down the front panel of the bay with the amber light, then slide out the drive you are replacing, and slide in the new drive. You can also see that a drive is not just the hard drive in a carrier. It has associated electronics.

Once you replace the failed drive, the blue lights come on, and the system is ready to use. However, the new drive has to go through a rebuild process, so it is not advisable to slide another drive out during this procedure, which can take several hours. The way I discovered this was when I crashed the server by sliding drive 4 out, sliding it back in, and then sliding drive 5 out before the rebuild on drive 4 was done. Kaleidescape called me and said, "We received a notice from your server that you were sliding drives in and out before the rebuild was done on the first drive you slid out. Don't do that."  Bottom line, don't invite trouble. However, the incident let me know that the server - Kaleidescape Ethernet connection was alive and well.

I can just see the note that was sent: "Alarm! Alarm! Neophyte Kaleidescape user is fiddling with the drive bays." In any case, I simply turned all three components off, then on again, and the system rebooted perfectly. No "Blue Screen of Death", thank goodness. Bulletproof, so far.

Each hard drive holds dozens of movies, and when your drives are full, you can order more, at $700 apiece.

The hard drives are configured for RAID, so that if one drive becomes defective, you don't lose any of your movies.

Installation

The review system had 140 Kaleidescape-owned movies installed on it, including several high definition titles. You can order collections of movies – such as the Top 150 Movies Ever Made, and Best Picture (Academy Award) Movies, directly from Kaleidescape or your dealer.  Kaleidescape will then ship you the collection of DVDs, and you will need to load them into your Kaleidescape system. If you order high definition titles (that Kaleidescape has licensed) at the same time you purchase your system, they will come preloaded on the system. If you order high definition movies later, they send them to you on a Kaleidescape Transport Disk (a hard drive). You will need to copy the content to your system (you insert the drive into an empty Kaleidescape drive bay) and then return the transport disk to Kaleidescape. The fact that it will store and play high definition movies is very important, as that is the direction TV viewing is heading.

Although loading movies onto the server is easy, it is time consuming. Each movie takes about half an hour to load from a DVD placed in the reader. There is no other way to load movies than doing it yourself with DVDs.

To load a DVD onto the server, you just open the reader drawer, place the DVD in the tray, and close the drawer, like any DVD player. The system automatically loads the movie, you don't have to push any buttons or activate any menu selections. While the movie is loading, the system goes to the Kaleidescape website via the Ethernet connection, and downloads the cover art that is used in the menu. If it is a movie they don't have in their cover art collection, they will locate it and send it to your server within a couple of business days.

DVDs are loaded onto the server as an exact copy, so the DVD menus are available if you wish. But, you can play movies directly from the server menu list, without having to go through the DVD menus, and that is a great feature. No waiting for menus to load, and no having to view all those movie previews that some DVD producers like to include. There is also no pause between layers, as the server puts them together seamlessly.

As mentioned, the three components are connected together with Cat-5 Ethernet cables. You also need an Cat-5 cable to connect to a local network so that the system can communicate with Kaleidescape for the cover art, new operating system upgrades, and service information. I ran a Cat-5 cable to my network router, and then I could access the system menu on my computer. You can also use a laptop to do this by a direct connection to the Kaleidescape system.

I assigned a permanent IP address to the Kaleidescape server, so that I could maintain a button on my web browser that would always go to the Kaleidescape server and let me access the menus.

When you access the sever by web browser, here is the main menu (Home).

On the left are movies that Kaleidescape recommends. On the right is the System Status, indicating how many movies you have installed and operating system update information.

The Control Panel lets you play movies from the computer menu. This is useful if you don't have a universal remote (Kaleidescape does not supply a remote control with the system). Once you buy a universal remote (or if you already have one), you go to the Kaleidescape website and download the commands into your remote. The menu shown below also appears on touch screen remotes, if you want to use them.

Clicking on Movie Library shows you a list of the movies you have. You can tick the boxes to the left of the movie titles and delete them if you need room to import new movies and don't want the old ones.

The Movie Import page shows when you loaded the various movies onto the server. I placed Toy Story in the reader, and about 15 minutes later, the Movie Import page showed that 7 minutes were left (first line under "Status", in the first figure below). Then, when it was done, that line read "Completed" (second figure shown below). At that point, Toy Story was listed in the Movie Library, ready for viewing.

The Preferences Page lets you tell the system how long you want paused movies to remain in a list, and recently imported movies to remain in a list. Passwords are also set up or changed on this page.

The Parental Control page lets you assign various levels of viewing permission to your children.

Click Here to Go to Part II

© Copyright 2004 Secrets of Home Theater & High Fidelity

Go to Table of Contents for this Issue

Go to Home Page

 

About Secrets

Register

Terms and Conditions of Use