Surround Sound Speaker Systems

Boston Acoustics A Series 5.1 Home Theater Speakers


Boston Acoustics A Series Home Theater Speakers In Use

Movie performance was evaluated with a Marantz SR5005, being fed signals from a Sony BDP-S550 Blu-Ray player, AppleTV 2, and an Audiolab 8200CDQ primarily used as a DAC via USB from a MacMini. Music evaluation used both the Marantz SR5005 in pure direct mode being fed from the Audiolab DAC and a Myryad MI-120 integrated amp. HDMI cables were all Kimber HD19, Interconnects were homemade Oyaide PA-02 with Neutrik ProFi RCA connectors, speaker cables were Furutech FS-301 terminated with Audioquest Banana plugs on the amp end, bare wire at the speaker end. I chose the Marantz receiver for testing for a few reasons. One, it's roughly in the same price range as would be used with speakers of this price. Two, seeing how Ken Ishiwata helped voice the speakers, I correctly guessed there would be a synergy between the Boston speakers and Marantz electronics.

I'll start with movie performance of the entire Boston Acoustics A series collective. The speakers were run in with white noise for a week at moderate level before performing an Audyssey calibration. At this point my room is now well treated for both a decently flat frequency response from 100hz on up and decay times. Confirmed by the fact that after performing three Audyssey calibration sessions, the equalization curves only applied no more than 2 decibels of correction. In fact besides the improvements to the subwoofer, the Audyssey calibration sounded almost identical to having the system off. As such, movie listening was performed with Audyssey engaged (for the improvements it brought below 100hz) and music was in pure direct mode on the SR5005.

The small center channel upon first inspection seemed an unlikely acoustic match to the large A 360 tower speakers. It proved to be unfounded. The A 225C formed a very realistic and well integrated front soundstage. Never standing out on its own, the A 225C went about smoothly blending in between the A 360s and provided real depth to the sonic picture. Audyssey identified the cross over point at 40hz and I had no need to move it upwards. The center has genuine bass response to 40hz and sounded worst when crossed over at any frequency higher than 40hz. The A 360 speakers were identified and run at full range.

Is the A 225C perfect? Far from it. No speaker at this price is without flaws. There is the ever present comb filtering when sitting significantly off axis. Male voices could at times sound overly chesty and boxy, while the tweeter's lack of air kept female voices from sounding lifelike.  These are small downsides in comparison to the strengths of the center channel. The A 225C has incredible macro dynamics, it sounds alive in a way most center channels don't. The frequency response is neutral with no obvious bias in the bass or treble. Midrange clarity is good for the money. Overall as with the rest of the system, the A 225C possesses a good balance of strengths and weaknesses.

Highest in the strengths column is the integration with the A 360 towers. It's superbly seamless. A feat I've not heard some center channel speakers costing ten times as much pull off.

The A 25 speakers were only auditioned as a surround speaker. Again, much like the A 225C center, the surround speakers blended in superbly with the A 360 towers. The mid-range of all the speakers is exceptionally consistent. Bass response is decent and as such the speakers were crossed over at 80hz by Audyssey. I manually retuned the cross over at 60hz since I have a natural 60hz dip in my room.

Sitting down to watch The Social Network the combination of the Boston A series speakers and Marantz receiver were simply magical.  There's a synergy between the two that is difficult to quantify. There are times when speakers and electronics form a synergy that is greater than the sum of the two. So much so, that for music listening I stopped using the vastly more refined and expensive (adjusted for inflation) Myryad integrated amp for music listening and just ran the Marantz SR5005 in pure direct mode fed by an Audiolab 8200CDQ via analog.

Having seen The Social Network several times in good theaters I was aware of just how good both the score and sound design sounded. Listening to it on blu-ray it was ten times better. The subtlety of the acoustic space of each location was simply staggering.

The combo of the Marantz and Boston speakers allowed the fluorescent light hum of the legal offices to contrast against, the reverberant halls of Harvard and the immensely detailed and bass deep score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross. The combo easily handled the smallest of details, to the loudest of passages, the night club scene stands out, as does dinner with Sean Parker. Dynamics are explosive but well controlled, quiet passages are filled with tension and effects steering is lightning fast. Movie watching had an immersive and enveloping quality. The sound field was truly 360 degrees with seamless panning between all the speakers.

If there is one weakness in the package it's the subwoofer. For most small to medium sized rooms the sub would work well, and if you take into account the price, it's a great sub. In my large room it struggled to balance pitch definition with output. The higher the output required, the less tuneful the bass sounded. Some port noise and cone break up could also be heard at reference levels in my space. It's a good sub for the price, but it doesn't deliver the refinement and level of performance the rest of the system is capable of.

Movie after movie the A series speakers delivered a superb listening experience. Whether the movie was Casino Royale or the distinctly more intimate and musical Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist the Boston Acoustics speakers (with the Marantz SR5005) delivered sonic gold. The entire listening experience is so balanced, so natural, so musical, it's just a treat on the ears. This despite knowing more expensive speakers deliver greater detail. Few speakers are just so pleasurable to listen to.

In music listening sessions one thing stood out. The A 360 towers are truly special and not just for the price. They deliver a musical performance (again, especially when partnered with Marantz electronics) that is emotionally engaging and rare regardless of price. If you value that je ne sais quoi of "musical" systems, this is one. There's nothing groundbreaking in terms of realism, resolution, or those typical "HiFi" qualities. There is however a solidity and cohesiveness to music that is warm, seductive and enjoyable. Sure, the A 360s lack treble detail and air, and the bass isn't the most forceful. The midrange isn't a transparent window the way the B&W CM8 speakers were. Instead the even frequency response, the great attack speed of notes and good dynamic capabilities of the A 360s combine with the slightly warm and forgiving sound of the Marantz SR5005 to render truly beautiful music, regardless of genre.

The drivers of the A 360 are superbly integrated and cohesive. The bass never overpowers the mids and highs, and keeps pace with the lightning fast 3" mid-range.

The 1" Kortec soft dome tweeter is smooth (though oddly, before break in, it was harsh beyond belief) with good detail and a taste of "air" though it's a small taste. The whole sonic image is impressively organic and you never get the impression that four drivers are present. Sonic images are seamless with good depth and a surprisingly low image height for such a tall speaker.

Whether the music was from The Glitch Mob and Rusko which is bass heavy Dub-Step to subtle tracks by Air or Charlotte Gainsbourg. The A360 speakers are truly music agnostic. One notable limitation, female voices do sound a bit reigned in. When listening to Emmy The Great's album Virtue, her voice lacked that shocking realism more expensive speakers can provide, but not once did that pull me away from the music. Rock and Pop tracks are conveyed with great enthusiasm and energy. Foster The People comes through with the kick drum leading the way in a realistic fashion at anti-social volume levels. Each layer of the mix sitting in its own space with great intensity and energy.

These speakers encourage you to stop analyzing music and just get up and enjoy moving to your favorite songs. I'll take that any day instead of overly analytical speakers. They're not perfect but they are good, very good.

Flaws? Yes, for starters they're not the most accurate when it comes to imaging. There's a sense of left, center, right with a diffuse image in between when listening in stereo. There's a midrange chestiness and female vocals sound less than realistic compared to stand mounts in the same price range. The tweeter is not extremely extended in frequency response and does gloss over details. This is a mixed blessing as it lends itself to a more enjoyable presentation with more modern recordings.