Go to Home Page

Go to Index for All Q&A

 

Q&A # 351 - June 12, 2003
 

Staff

 

Q When I hook up my TEAC A-1D's preamp outputs in either a self powered sub or a power amp/speaker setup there is a power on/off thump in the system that the preamp outputs are connected to. We tried the one at the shop where I got it from, and the same problem was there regardless of sub or power amp. What I am looking for is a circuit that I can add to the preamp output that will stop or at least lessen the thump. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

A Turn-on thump is very common and not something that would damage your equipment, unless it was a result of a short or some other defect. Turn-off thump is sometimes there as well. The only way to get it to stop is to turn on the preamplifier first, then the power amp and subwoofer a few seconds later. When powering down, turn off the power amp and subwoofer first, then the preamplifier a few seconds later. You can get surge protectors that turn different components on and off in sequence.

T

Q I purchased a Denon 2800 MKII DVD player a few months ago, and it appears to have the CUE (chroma bug). Denon advised me that they tried to mask the CUE, but it is still noticeable to me. The Denon 2900 universal player has now been released, which has been advertised as CUE-free. Do you think that the Denon 2900 is a better video performer than the 2800MKII?

A The Denon 2900 universal player is not CUE-free, unfortunately, and most other brands that we have tested are not CUE-free either. It is taking longer than expected to work this bug out of manufacturing. The Denon 1600 is CUE-free, but it is not a universal player, although it has DVD-A. We are not satisfied with any of the new DVD players we have tested lately. I hate to say this, but it looks like we may have to purchase separate DVD players from DVD-A and/or SACD players to get all the formats and have a CUE-free video. There are some A/V publications out there that don't consider CUE a serious issue, but we at Secrets do, and we know that Secrets readers do as well.

T

Q In a 7.1 system, do you recommend dipole surround speakers all the way around or just for the rear surround speakers? I have heard conflicting opinions on this. Since you always substantiate you answers very well, I'm very interested in your suggestions.

A The THX recommendation is dipoles on the sides and direct projecting speakers in the rear. I tested this in my recent review of the Onix Rocket RSS-300 dipoles, and I tend to agree with the recommendation. I like the very diffuse sound on the sides.

T

Q I noticed recently that when I listen to a music CD, the singer is no longer centered in the sound field. I double checked my speaker balance with the Avia DVD and a sound meter. The speaker balance is fine. CDs played on DVDs are fine. How do I find out if the problem is with the CD player or my receiver?

A This problem could be caused by a number of things. One is that CDs are stereo, so you are probably using Pro Logic or one of the other DSP modes to give you surround sound. The center channel with Pro Logic is decoded from any mono signal in the stereo channels. If you have one of the modified Pro Logic modes engaged, that might be throwing things off balance. For example, a DSP mode might be putting some or all of the center in the left and right channels. With a DVD, you are likely using Dolby Digital, which has a dedicated center channel track, and this is unaffected by the various DSP modes.

T

Q First, I'd like to again (I've written in before) compliment you on maintaining such a great site. There's so much wrong with the internet, but sites like yours give us all hope!

My question is a little different. I've been into home theater for many years, and am pretty familiar with the ins and outs of playback. However, I'm now looking for a digital camcorder, which leads me to this question . . . .

What do you think is the "better" feature, a 0.68 megapixel progressive scan CCD, or interlaced recording with a 1.3 megapixel CCD? It seems that JVC is discontinuing their old progressive camera, in favor of a high resolution interlaced one, but the old model (GR-DV2000U) can be had new for the same price. I'd really like to get your opinion before a purchase.

A Sometimes DV camera manufacturers add up the megapixels if the camera has 3 CCDs (one each for red, green, and blue), or they may only list the megapixel count for 1 of the CCDs in a 3-CCD camera, so you have to check for that issue. Secondly, in my opinion, progressive video is vastly superior to interlaced video. I have a Canon DV camera that will let me take video in 4:3, 16:9, progressive, and interlaced. I use 4:3 progressive (480p) at present, as scenes with motion don't have any of the staircasing along diagonal objects in motion that interlaced video has. I will be moving to 16:9 shortly (still 480p), and storing it on anamorphic DVD for use with my 16:9 projector. Lastly, JVC has a new DV camera that is 16:9 native and will take video at 720p (30), which means it is an HDTV consumer DV camera. Although HDTV 720p is actually 720p (60), even just 30 frames per second of 720p are going to look really great. It is about $3,500. More such cameras are sure to follow from several manufacturers, and the price will come down. Assuming you have a progressive scan 16:9 digital TV, I would suggest getting one of these new cameras. Even if you don't have a progressive scan TV, I would still suggest getting one of these cameras, as it will also let you take your videos in 480i until you do get that new TV.

T

Q I have a Sony DVP 7700 player that is connected to a Denon AVR 5700 receiver using a BetterCables digital coax cable. Now, when I play a DVD with a Dolby Digital (DD) track only, the player detects and feeds the DD signal to the receiver which puts itself in DD mode. However, when I play a DVD with both DD and DTS tracks, the Sony doesn't seem to detect the DTS signal, and consequently falls back to DD. For example, playing "Jurassic Park 3" yields DD only. I have configured the Sony to enable DTS output, but without success - the player's DTS LED indicator never lights up and the receiver's input mode never budges from DD. I've battled long and hard and obviously still missed something. Can you set me straight on this one?

A There are still problems with some players not being able to play a format with certain discs. It is not the same for every player. It may be that the 7700 has a problem with DTS on that movie disc. However, go into the menu and check the configuration for bitstream vs. analog on DD vs. DTS. Make sure it is bitstream out. On the other hand, the fact that the DTS light on your 7700 is not coming on leads me to believe it is just one of those player-specific disc issues.

T

Q Can I look somewhere to get some feedback on the best value surround sound receivers, DVD players, and CD players. I have only been able to get subjective opinions based upon what someone carries. I have ordered some Vandersteen speakers and would like to have either a surround sound receiver that would work well with the speakers for audio and surround or a cost-effective separates option. Same question for a DVD player. For example, is there a way to find out the "best" DVD player on the market for under $1,000 and the same question for a surround (5.1) receiver, single -disc vs. multi disc CD player?

A There really is no "best" component in an absolute sense, because we all give our opinions based, in the final analysis, on subjective feelings. However, our Benchmarks on DVD players are an excellent source of info. At this point, that new Onkyo TX-SR800 receiver that we reviewed in April of this year is terrific in your price range. For DVD players, the Denon DVD-1600 is top notch (it is reviewed in our Benchmark pages). For CD players, either use the CD capabilities of the DVD player, or spend about $200 for whatever multi-disc CD changer that you can find at CostCo.

T

Q I have a Sony HD200 DirecTV receiver hooked up to an HK AVR-7000 receiver using the optical connection. Whenever I change from a non-DD program to one broadcasting DD I hear a loud pop from the speakers. Any ideas?

A Yes, this is not unusual. The receiver sees the DD signal coming in and switches the circuit from analog processing over to decoding the digital signal. A transient is produced during this switching process, and that produces the pop. Turn the volume down when switching to the DD program.

© Copyright Secrets of Home Theater & High Fidelity

Go to Home Page

 

Go to DVD Player Benchmark

About Secrets

Register

Go to Primer Introduction

Terms and Conditions of Use