Daily Blog – John E. Johnson, Jr. – February 29, 2008: THE FUTURE OF HD DVD PLAYERS.

After Steve’s blog the other day, suggesting that we go to Amazon.com and buy what we want in the HD DVD movie closeout, I did so, picking up some movies that are in both formats. The HD DVD versions were half price. Interestingly, it appears that the studios who released their movies in both HD DVD and Blu-ray, encoded them at the more restricted bit rate of HD DVD for both disc types. So, the Blu-ray versions are no better than the HD DVD versions even though they theoretically could be (if the Blu-ray versions had been encoded at the higher bit rate capability of Blu-ray).

I have one HD DVD player, a Toshiba. I also have an LG HD DVD/Blu-ray drive (about $340) in my media server. At some point, the HD DVD players will break down. And when that happens, there won’t be a replacement available.  Even if you go to Amazon.com today and buy an extra HD DVD player at the very reduced prices, and store it away for when your current HD DVD player breaks, it will eventually stop working as well. So, what happens to your collection of HD DVDs then?

What I am doing is transferring my HD DVDs to my media server, using AnyDVD. This is software that some people use to copy DVDs, HD DVDs, and Blu-ray discs to their hard drives. It is not a legal software program in the sense that it is available in the USA. The movie manufacturers would sue them up one side and down the other if they were based here. The problem is that the program is used by some to steal movies, that is, copy borrowed or rented discs. I agree that is wrong. However, I don’t see a problem in just copying the discs that I own, to my media server, for backup protection. The discs do get scratched, and as I said, eventually, there will not be any working HD DVD players to play them. I really don’t think Hollywood has a disagreement with this approach. It is the copying of movies that consumers have not purchased that is the issue. The movie studios have a right to protect their investments. But we, as consumers, also have the right to protect our investments. Right? Right.

So, what I am saying here is that I hope manufacturers and consumers can come to some sort of official agreement as to how we can store our movies on transferrable media such that we can protect them with backup hard drives, and be able to continue to enjoy them for many years. Right now, that is in danger. I know there are many other consumers out there who are copying their movies to hard drives, or who want to do that. They are afraid to talk about it. As an A/V editor, I have to talk about it.

3 Responses to “Daily Blog – John E. Johnson, Jr. – February 29, 2008: THE FUTURE OF HD DVD PLAYERS.”

  1. Kieran Says:

    Thank you for talking about it! I agree with you. I remember in the late 90′s, tools that allowed you to rip an audio CD were hard to find, and often sites that hosted the software were taken down in a matter of days. Now, it has become entirely commonplace to rip one’s CD collection to mp3 or some other compressed audio format, for use on portable music players, or on a media server. I know a lot of people who’ve recently been transferring their entire CD collection to a lossless codec format on their media servers. Why is this exact same action taboo, when it’s done with movies? Hopefully, the day will come soon when ripping your video disc collection (dvd / brd /hddvd) to your hard drive is as common and as acceptable as doing so with CDs is today.

    Last year, I traveled a LOT for work. I would bring my laptop with me, and I would enjoy watching movies on it during the evenings. Thing is, I didn’t want to bring 5 or so DVDs with me, and risk breaking them or scratching them in my luggage. But a ripped DVD took too much room on my laptop’s small HDD. Compressing the videos to DivX or XviD format worked great. A 4GB movie could be shrunk to ~1GB with no loss in quality (especially when viewed on a laptop screen), and I could fit several movies on my laptop to last me for the week without taking too much working space from my HDD.

  2. John Johnson Says:

    Well, I suspect the reason that the studios are so much more concerned about copies of movies getting spread around is that movies cost a hundred million dollars to produce, while a recording is about a hundred thousand dollars.

  3. Maurice J Says:

    Toshiba can do the same as Pioneer did with their Laserdisc combo player and make it available for purchase on its website. Or if BD decides to max the encoding on the disc, make final spec players available, and price the disc the same as DVD then those HD DVDs will be reissued as BDs and you can upgrade to a better disc. For me Bluray must do this because I won’t pay the higher cost since the “war” is over. But I will take advantage of BOGOF on titles I want if Amazon has one again.
    It’s the same thing that was done with LD and DVD disc as the technology advanced and features were added for value. A way to get you to spend your money and feel good about it. I feel good about the money I saved on HD DVD and some BD.

What's Your Opinion?

Post Your Opinion Below

If you'd like to submit a blog post to the Secrets of Home Theater and High Fidelity Blog,
please send to editor@hometheaterhifi.com.

Magazine Web Design - AdvonteMedia